Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa To Pay $12,000,000 To Victim Over Rape Case

In a story that encapsulates everything I know about how Calvary Chapel deals with abuse victims, The Roys Report say that CCCM is paying a victim 12 million bucks to settle a suit,

“Evidence released exclusively to Roys Report (RR) shows Calvary Chapel senior leaders were told numerous times that Harman, an ex-convict, was violent and struggled with addiction. But they did not take it seriously.

Calvary Chapel school administrator Kenny Wood told a parent raising concerns about the wrestling coach to “go away and leave me alone,” documents show.  Former senior Pastor Brian Brodersen reportedly said the parents had “a vendetta” and allegations of physical violence did not need to be seriously investigated because the woman reporting them was “borderline crazy.” “

Without fail, whenever I inquired about a woman making an abuse claim or who was seeking a divorce from an abusive pastor, I was told that the woman was some form of “crazy”.

CCCM protected the perp despite numerous complaints and had the usual CCCM team try to cover it up.

Whatever measure of respect I had for Brian Brodersen is now gone…he is still carrying on “the Calvary way”.

I’m not on the inside of CCCM anymore, but I suspect that this ruling will impact the church even after insurance covers what it will…I don’t know how much of the money Chuck Smith accumulated is left.

I heartily commend the article to your reading…

 

 

You may also like...

23 Responses

  1. jtk says:

    Whoaaa.

    How much money do they have?!

  2. Michael says:

    jtk,

    No one outside the board really knows. 15-20 years ago I heard anywhere from 300-500 million.

    They owned a radio station that was printing money…and a lot has changed in the recent years.

  3. jtk says:

    “As Harman remembers it, no one on the pastoral staff or the board of elders asked him questions about his criminal past, his spiritual growth, his relationship with God or his theology.”

    I feel sick and don’t think I can read anymore….

    I should catch up with you sometime…..

  4. Michael says:

    jtk,

    That’s the way it’s always worked…
    Catch up when you can…

  5. Laura Figueroa-Scott says:

    And he said, ‘No, you should do as the Lord leads,’”

    That’s what plausible deniability looks and sounds like, Calvary Chapel-style.

  6. Muff Potter says:

    A good tort attorney can smell money like a good hound can smell treed raccoons.
    This wouldn’t even be happening if it (Calvary Chapel) was just a little backwater congregation run by Chester the Molester.

  7. pstrmike says:

    Wow. Day of reckoning…….

    I love the borderline crazy defense. When I was in Calvary, the term I heard over and over among pastors was “batshit crazy.” I never understood the adjective batshit.

    Good point, Muff. Always follow the money trail.

  8. Grendal Hanks says:

    I am so glad we left this place! 🙏🏼

  9. Terry says:

    Is making every man you have on staff a pastor? When checking out local churches online, I noticed the closest CC had every male staff member, down to groundskeeper as pastor. I ask, because, um, wrestling coach.

  10. JD says:

    Unfortunately thuggery was present at times in Calvary Chapel churches we attended. At the time
    I often thought of the wisdom of
    Proverbs 3:31.
    What a sickening state of affairs.

  11. BrideofChrist says:

    According to the Roys Report article, this wrestling coach who worked at the church’s high school married an 18 year old student from the school immediately after she graduated. I attended a large Calvary Chapel Church in So Cal that had a high school. The same thing happened – the principal of the church school married a girl from the high school immediately after her graduation from the church school. I had known this young girl since she was 9 years old as we were close friends with her parents. I was shocked and horrified that this was considered acceptable by the church. In the real world, a principal would lose his position over something like this. I attended Calvary Chapel for 30 years and realized that they think the rules that govern our society just don’t apply to them. A recent example of this is the many Calvary Chapels that refused to apply the mask mandate during the Covid outbreak. Calvary Chapels act like they are “above the law”. They make their own rules. Then they are surprised when they must face the consequences. I stopped attending Calvary Chapel about ten years ago once I realized how unhealthy the church environment there was – there was little accountability for the ( all male) leadership. The “Moses Model” of church governance is a recipe for disaster. I was saved at a Calvary Chapel Church in the seventies. I think the church started out filled with the Holy Spirit, but sin crept in, and it flourished there.

  12. JD says:

    Quite a few naive Christians are inoculated with the universal Nonrockaboatus Vaccine.
    And if you don’t like needles you can get a sugar cube in your koolaid minicup.
    You gadda you gadda you gadda.

  13. Michael says:

    BrideofChrist,

    How many times have we seen this scenario?

    Good on you for seeing it and moving on…

  14. BrideofChrist says:

    When I look back at my 30 plus years of involvement with Calvary Chapel – from its inception in the seventies – I think of Matthew 13:32 ” Though it is the smallest of seeds, yet when it grows, it is the,largest of plants and becomes a tree, so that the birds of the air come and perch on its branches.” Older Calvary Chapel attendees remember the musical group.”Mustard Seed Faith”. All Christians all know the parable of the tiny mustard seed growing into a great church revival. It’s a beautiful parable, but it comes with a warning (or prediction) . From ‘Bibletools.org’ : “Birds are naturally attracted to the mustard seed.. Matthew identifies the birds of the air as the wicked one in Matthew 4. Mark connects them with Satan ( Mark 4:4)’ and likens them to “the devil”( Luke 8:5). In the parable of the mustard tree, Jesus predicts the birds of the air would lodge in the branches once the tree grew into a giant tree. The “birds” in the parable are actually demons led by the “prince of the power of the air” and they have continually tried to infiltrate the church. Satan moves quickly to implant its agents of false doctrine while appearing to be true Christians. “I witnessed Calvary Chapel grow from a mustard seed into a huge tree, and then I watched the “birds of the air” fill that same tree until its branches broke. Every time I think of Calvary Chapel now I think of a huge tree filled with dark,ugly birds. Is it the false doctrine of the “Moses Model” that caused Calvary’s fall fron grace, or was it the sins of its leaders that were never properly dealt with? Unrooted sin in a church will obviously multiply-everyChristian who reads their Bible knows this to be true.

  15. Tracy says:

    I just learned about this from my daughter. She graduated from Calvary Chapel high in 2016. She had a good experience at the school, but as far as the church, I definitely got burned out on them fast. I was saved there as a high schooler myself, back when Greg Laurie did Monday night altar calls. But the church itself never felt right for me. Specifically the way they reacted to 9/11, and what was said by Chuck that following Sunday, caused me some trauma. They were all about fear and it worked! I’m just grateful that my daughter met some amazing kids at the school, and had some good teachers. Kenny Wood was vice principal back then and I’m so disappointed. He seemed so kind. 💔
    Also never liked Broderson, or how he took over once Chuck died!
    This is my first time to your page. Michael how were you connected to Calvary?

  16. G says:

    I grew up with Jake long ago in Southern California. We went to the same church in Orange for at least all of junior high and high school if not longer. I found out later as an adult that his dad was a child abuser and beat the shit out of him at least on a weekly basis. And thus the cycle of abuse continues.

    Shame on Calvary chapel, both the Smiths and Brodersons, for allowing this to abuse to thrive under their watch. May they be damned for shirking their higher responsibility.

    This makes the second Calvary chapel I used to attend where a pastor was raping or molesting a (child) victim. Look up Roshad Thomas from CC Tallahassee.

    This is why I no longer go to any church.

  17. Michael says:

    Tracy,

    I was thrown under the CC bus forty years ago.

    25 years ago, I started this site…you missed all the good stuff. 🙂

  18. Michael says:

    G,

    Sorry to hear that…a lot of folks here have given up on church for these reasons…

  19. JD says:

    Two of the CCs we attended had kids leaders who were molesters, one kids pastor at another was violent and we got kicked out for confronting him.

  20. G says:

    If I recall his dad was a deacon or elder of the church which is just the cherry on top.

    Grateful for you Michael for having a space for the tribeless.

  21. Tracy says:

    Michael that’s such a shame. 😔
    When you first get saved and have a “mountaintop” experience, and I definitely did, that church and that time can feel sacred to you. I never expected this from them. 😔
    Twenty-five years ago would be 01. Were you still there on 9/11? Do you remember Chuck’s sermon that following Sunday? I will never forget it. It was the beginning of the end there for me. I felt God calling me after that to a far less fear-mongering church.
    If you weren’t there, it went something like this: The church was packed, some were standing, some sitting on the floor. Chuck began with these words:
    “I can see many of you are here, and that is good. I can see many of you are scared, and that is also good. You should be. You should be.”
    He went on to speculate that we may encounter bombings, nuclear war, and all manner of terrible things.
    I was petrified. 😳 End times was terrifying to me back then. I went through a really hard time for awhile.
    Some time later, I ran into an old friend from a church I had attended during high school in the 90s. I said hi and asked him what the pastor had preached on that same Sunday. He said, the Beatitudes. “Blessed are the peacemakers. Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness”. I felt like the Lord had sent this friend straight to me! I started attending that church instead, and stayed for many years.
    I forgave Calvary and decided to send my daughter there once she started high school many years later, because she needed a good Christian school. But I always kept an eye on any end-times messages, and made sure she was ok. By that point, they had actually toned all that down quite a bit.
    I am supremely grateful the wrestling coach never got anywhere near her.

  22. Tracy says:

    Sorry just read it again and you said forty years, not 25, haha! 🤦‍♀️ My bad.

  23. Michael says:

    Tracy,

    I never have had a “mountain top”experience…I did have high expectations for behaviors and actions that were utterly demolished.

    I was long gone from anything CC related by 2001…they thought they were sending me into the desert…in the desert I found real theologians…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Phoenix Preacher

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading