Notre Dame de Paris: Duane W.H. Arnold, PhD
Even as the flames raced up the spire, conclusions poured forth from social media. “It’s part of a left wing conspiracy linked to the vandalism of French churches.” “It’s God’s judgement on the French secular state.” On and on they went…
To be truthful, the fire that consumed so much of the Cathedral of Notre Dame, Paris, was simply a tragedy. Investigations will determine the cause, but it appears likely that it was an accident, possibly caused by a worker in the scaffolding. Yet, regardless of the findings, rest assured that the conspiracy theorists will continue.
It seems that when a tragedy occurs there will always be those who will look for a cause that is “outside of ourselves”. Â
Yet, even as internet pundits opined, those on the streets of Paris had a different reaction. There was stunned silence and then prayers and the singing of hymns. Like well trained grief counselors, they seemed to know instinctively that a time of tragedy does not call for explanations, but for comfort and faith.
For well over thirty years, year in and year out, Notre Dame has been a part of my life. Just a few weeks ago, I spent half a day wandering through the glorious interior of the Cathedral. I visited the Treasury and marveled at the centuries of devotion wrought in silver and gold, silk and parchment. I stopped in a side chapel and lit a candle, praying for my friend in southern Oregon. Â
Now it is gone, but not completely. A remnant remains. Those who prayed and sang hymns will now help in rebuilding. It will not be easy. It will call for commitment and sacrifice. It will not be rebuilt by talking about it, or blaming others for what has happened. Yet, stone by stone, day by day, it can be restored to its former glory.
As my friend in southern Oregon likes to say…
Make your own application.
Well said, Duane…and thank you for the candle…
Duane,
I believe God can bring about good out of evil. Whether or not the fire was an accident or not, it resulting in destruction. I am truly sorry for everyone who has experienced a sense of loss.
In a different venue, I was wrestling with something from Eccles: “For everything there is a season…a time to break down, and a time to build up”
Two questions I asked were: What season is it? and How do we discern the season?
The only sure thing I could point to is the foundation. If the foundation is strong, then building can take place. On the other hand, if the foundation is weak, then building on it would be in vain.
I think the Parisians will have to answer those questions for themselves. If they are determined to re-build, is it for a museum? Is it for a monument? Or might it be for a new church, for a generation of Christians, for whom Christ would be the foundation of their faith? If they rebuild, I hope it’s for the latter reason.
Michael
Many thanks… and, whether here or there, you’re always in my prayers…
Jean
It is historical. It is cultural. It is a place of pilgrimage. It is a place of worship with a Christian community that gathers daily for Mass…
It was an incredible structure, a monument to the God given skills and devotion of centuries ago
Was there an intentional evil act or neglect to protect? I doubt that the French government will allow any conclusion that puts them in a bad light… It cannot be “rebuilt” in my opinion – only replaced. . ?
Em
“It cannot be “rebuilt” in my opinion – only replaced…”
In the 19th century, much was rebuilt by the architect Eugene Viollet-le-duc (including the central spire that fell). Seeing the films of the inferno, I’m surprised so much has survived. It was owing to the bravery of the firemen and their chaplain that so many of the treasures were carried out and saved. I’m hoping that in 5-10 years, I will once again light a candle for my friends in Notre Dame…
Dr. Duane, i was thinking of the incredible ancient oak timbers… ?
Em,
Yes… hard to find timbers that date from the eighth century!
Dr. Duane… ?
I meant that there are no oak trees of that great size anymore
Didn’t Napoleon order the refurbishing when he was emperor ?
I would love to have seen the interior. I assume the organ is no more…
I was listening to a Chicago radio station and the on-the-air folks were talking about Notre Dame.
One guy said he was there once with someone who wasn’t a believer and he was stunned by
the beauty of the place.
I think sometimes as Protestants we forget that nontangibles like beauty and wonder can be
a door to Christian transcendence. Paraphrasing Lewis, they may find it evokes a desire that’s
not of this world…
Not everyone is convinced by hard-core apologetics.
Em
Napoleon ordered the first rebuilding after the depredations of the Revolution. Mid-century, further work was done. It appears the great organ (8,000 pipes) has miraculously survived!
bob1
Could not agree more. There’s a reason that God promises “to give them [us] beauty for ashes”. It is essential to who we are as human beings. I think we neglect art and music to our peril as it limits the manner in which we can touch people’s lives. It is not all about intellectual cognition… or at least it shouldn’t be…